Three great, but quite different whitetail cartridges. The venerable, versatile, long-action .30-06 (middle) with the short-action. .30-30 (left) and the short-action .243 Winchester (right). The .30-30 wasn’t specifically designed as a member of the short-action group because that designation didn’t come into popular parlance until the .308 Win. standardized it beginning in 1953. (Ron Spomer/)
Admittedly, one of the most overdone topics in the hunting industry is the Best Whitetail Cartridge. Every outdoor publication and website has done it. Some several times. A few annually. And still, no one agrees.
Why? Because the question is too broad. As if every whitetail weighed 300 pounds and lived on the edge of Saskatchewan’s buffalo plains where 300 yards is considered close. Or 100 pounds and haunted South Carolina swamps where 75 yards is considered a long shot.
A baker’s dozen of .30-caliber cartridges shows how the .30-30 (2nd from left) and .30-06 (7th from left) fit in the pantheon. Clearly the .30-30 is a middle-of-the-pack contender. (Ron Spomer/)
Nevertheless, the articles keep popping up. That’s not all bad, because it gets hunters arguing and discussing stuff, if not thinking, and at least sharing some ideas. A few generate a hint of light with all their heat.
This article will avoid describing the Best Whitetail Cartridge in favor of comparing three of the more famous. Surely thousands, if not millions of deer hunters, consider one of these the ultimate whitetail round, whether it is or isn’t. So let’s dive right in.
.30-30 Winchester

































































































